A few petitions in bankruptcy
were presented for filing
yesterday in the office of the
Clerk of the United States Court
for the Southern District of New
York, under the new Federal
bankruptcy law. The bearers of
the documents were informed that
petitions could not be filed
until today inasmuch as the act,
which was passed by Congress on
July 1, provides that no
petition for voluntary
bankruptcy shall be filed
"within one month of the passage
thereof, and that no petition
for involuntary bankruptcy shall
be filed within four months of
the passage thereof." The "one
month" after the passage of this
act is held to have expired
yesterday, and petitions for
voluntary bankruptcy therefore
may be filed today.
Judge Addison Brown of the
United States District Court
will have the appointment under
the new bankruptcy law, of a
certain number of referees in
bankruptcy who in all bankruptcy
proceedings begun hereafter will
take the places of the old time
registers. Judge Brown also has
the power to appoint trustees in
cases where creditors fail to
elect trustees, and the trustees
under the new law will take the
places of the assignees under
the old law.
Under the new law a trustee will
take title to a bankrupt's
property by operation of law,
and not by assignment. The last
clause of the new law explicitly
provides that proceedings
commenced under State insolvency
laws before the passage of this
act shall not be affected by it.
William S. Kelley of the law
firm of Graybill & Keiley, 229
Broadway in discussing this new
bankruptcy law yesterday said: "
An important feature of this act
is the right that it gives to a
trial by jury in respect of the
question of the alleged
bankrupt's insolvency. The law
also gives a very explicit
definition of insolvency as
follows: " A person shall be
deemed insolvent within the
provisions of this act, whenever
the aggregate of his property,
exclusive of any property which
he may have conveyed,
transferred, concealed, or
removed, or permitted to be
concealed or removed, with
intent to defraud, hinder, or
delay his creditors, shall not
at a fair valuation be
sufficient in amount to pay his
debt."
"Any person may file a voluntary
petition in bankruptcy under the
new law and the question of the
amount of the debt does not
enter into the matter. No
corporation, however, may file a
voluntary petition. A peculiar
feature and one which I think is
going to be a serious question
for judicial consideration, is
whether, under this new law,
railroad companies or insurance
corporations can be adjudged
bankrupts. There is no mention
of railroad or insurance
companies in the section of the
law defining who may become
bankrupts. Sub-division B of
Section 4 says: 'Any natural
person, except a wage-earner, or
a person engaged chiefly in
farming, or in the tillage of
the soil, any unincorporated
company, and any corporation
engaged principally in
manufacturing, trading,
printing, publishing, or
mercantile pursuits, owing debts
to the amount of $1,000 or over,
may be adjudged an involuntary
bankrupt upon default, or an
impartial trial,' & c. You
observe there is nothing in that
paragraph that applies to either
the railroad or the insurance
business.
"Another peculiar phase of this
new law is the provision with
regard to co-partnerships. It is
here provided that all of the
partners must join in the filing
of a voluntary petition in
bankruptcy by a co-partnership.
Under the old law one partner
could act. The jurisdiction of
the State courts is preserved in
respect of suits brought by
Trustees. The new law abolishes
registers and assignees and
designates in their places
referees and Trustees; it
likewise reduces the expenses of
administering the trust to a
minimum. When a petitioner must
deposit with the clerk of the
court $25, of which $10 goes to
the referee, $10 to the clerk
and $5 to the Trustee. If there
be more than one Trustee the
five dollars is divided among
the Trustees, no matter how many
there may be. If in a voluntary
application the petitioner makes
affidavit that he is without
means there need be no money
deposit. In addition to his $10,
the referee is to receive 1 per
cent on all sums paid as
dividends and 1 1/2 per cent, on
the amount paid upon the
confirmation of a composition. A
Trustee, in addition to the $5
is entitled to a commission not
to exceed 3 per cent. on the
first 5,000, 2 per cent. on the
second $5,000 and 1 per cent. on
the remainder.
"The point raised that no
petitions in bankruptcy could be
legally filed at the present
time because no rules have been
promulgated by the Supreme Court
of the United States does not
impress me as being important.
The law is explicit in telling
just what shall be done, and
therefore, in my opinion,
persons can proceed under the
terms of the act itself until
the rules of procedure are
provided. Section 30 says: All
necessary rules, forms, and
orders as to procedure and for
carrying this act into force and
effect shall be prescribed and
may be amended from time to time
by the Supreme Court of the
United States."
"It is worthy of note that this
new law gives a new definition
to the term wage earner." It
says that "a wage earner shall
mean an individual who works for
wages, salary, or hire, at a
rate of compensation not
exceeding $1,500 per year."
Mr. Walgrave Harlock, who has
been studying the new bankruptcy
law very closely, directed
attention to an interesting
point yesterday. Under the old
bankruptcy laws, if a bankrupt
omitted from his schedules,
without intent or fraud, any
items of his indebtedness, those
items nevertheless became wiped
out by his discharge in
bankruptcy. The new law provides
that if a debt due to a creditor
is not placed in a bankrupt's
schedules with the name of the
creditor, if known to the
bankrupt, such debt is not
affected by the bankrupt's
discharge and consequently it
will continue to stand as a
legal claim against the
bankrupt. "This provision" said
Mr. Harlock, "will have the
effect of making insolvent
debtors, and lawyers also, more
careful in preparing their
papers. Of course a man who goes
through bankruptcy proceedings
desires to be discharged from
every debt."
Wants the New Act Applied
A case having a bearing on the
new Federal bankruptcy law came
before Justice Beekman in
Special Term, Part I., of the
Supreme Court, yesterday.
Application was made in behalf
of George F. Vietor, a creditor
of Jacob and Martin M. Lewis,
doing business as woolen dealers
in Church Street, under the name
of Charles Lewis & Brothers, to
restrain the Lewises and Isaac
K. Cohn and his wife Rebecca and
the Sheriff from proceeding
further with the disposition of
the assets of the firm. Counsel
for the plaintiff claimed that
the creditors of the firm unless
the injunction were granted,
would be deprived of any share
in the assets of the firm which
had admitted its bankruptcy when
judgment was confessed. He asked
that the Cohns be restrained
from collecting the amount in
the hands of the Sheriff, and
that Nathan Lewis be enjoined
from collecting the outstanding
debts until after Nov. 1. By
that time the petition of the
creditors to have the firm
adjudged insolvent would be
filed in the United States court
under the new Bankruptcy act.
The United States District
Court, the plaintiff's counsel
said, would then take charge of
the assets and see that all of
the creditors were treated
similarly in the distribution of
the assets. He declared that
this application was perfectly
fair and legal, as he did not
ask that the transfer of the
outstanding debts, or that the
confessed judgment be set aside,
but merely desired that all the
creditors be fairly dealt with.
It was impossible at present to
go to the United States Court,
as the compulsory petition could
not be filled until November,
and unless the injunction were
granted there would be nothing
left at that time for the
creditors. In opposition to the
motion it was contended that the
Supreme Court had no
jurisdiction, as the bankruptcy
law is a Federal law and can be
administered only by the United
States courts. This application,
it was maintained, should have
been made to the Federal court.
Justice Beekman reserved his
decision.