The old fable that the streets
in America are paved with gold,
which has lured many an
immigrant here only to endure
cold and hunger, is being
repeated in a new form and is
likely to throw upon our town an
army of ignorant foreigners this
summer, for whom there is no
possibility of finding work. The
new bait is not golden paved
streets, but but the prospect of
work on the rapid transit
tunnel.
The steamship agents are
spreading all through Southern
Europe stories of the plentiful
work and big wages which this
enterprise will supply. Their
glowing promises are being
supported by letters home from
Italians already in this city,
who have found in work for Mr.
McDonald and other contractors
heretofore, wealth beyond any
dreams they had indulged in
their sunny homes. it is not
strange that these alien
visitors should misunderstand
the conditions under which this
work is to be done, and perhaps
it not strange that the
steamship companies should
foster any delusion which
promises to increase their
business, but the combination of
tales is likely to bring
suffering to a great many
innocent immigrants and to make
a troublesome situation in the
city.
For years the bulk of the
employees of city contractors
have been Italians. They came
here from poverty so abject that
they were willing to work for
prices which were scorned by men
who had had a few more years'
experience of American comfort.
There has been nothing to
prevent contractors hiring men
at the lowest prices save the
"pull" of the politicians
through whom contracts are
awarded. That has usually been
sufficient to put a certain
number of party workers on the
pay rolls at pretty good wages,
but it has left an army of day
laborers to be supplied from
among the recent immigrants who
were willing to work cheaply.
The conditions for this tunnel
work are changed. The law fixes
the eight hour day for laborers
on the tunnel and it provides
that union wages shall be paid.
Under those circumstances the
contractor has nothing to gain
and a great deal to lose by
employing immigrant labor. In
the first place, the man who has
been accustomed to live on the
small pay and scant fare which
prevail in Southern and Eastern
Europe cannot do as much work as
the meat-eating American working
man. That is as idle as to
expect to get the same steam
from half a ton of coal as from
a ton. It is a question of fuel
in both cases.
If the contractor must pay the
highest current wages he
certainly wants the most
efficient workmen, and they are
those accustomed to the rushing
American ways. Then the
contractor has a great deal to
gain by pleasing the politicians
who recommend workmen. In the
course of his three years'
undertaking the politicians can
put a good many obstacles in his
way if they are so disposed.
Friends at court never hurt
anybody. The district leaders
will recommend voters.
There are enough of them in New
York who will be glad to take
tunnel jobs at short hours to
dig the whole of the big ditch.
This absorption of the best
laborers on the tunnel may throw
open other employments to the
new comers and it will
undoubtedly strengthen the labor
market in the city. But there
are enough idle men in New York
today to dig the tunnel if only
all the idle were willing to
work. The tunnel will not clean
out the crowds in parks nor
lessen the lines at free bread
distributions, probably, but it
will help honest men who want
work and cannot find it. It will
bring in men who can become
voters long before the job is
done and get influence in that
way. Between these classes the
places left for immigrants will
be few, even if no declaration
against employing aliens is
made.
These facts ought to be
circulated in the regions from
which our immigrants are drawn,
before the summer rush now
preparing gets under way. They
will not be, however. The rush
will come and the Commissioners
of Immigration ought to send
back as many of those for whom
the prospect of work is almost
hopeless as the law will allow.
The tunnel will be a blessing to
all who get work on it, but it
ought not to be allowed to draw
in an army of foreigners to beg
or starve.