1600s
 

Thomas Willett 1665 Thomas Delavall 1666 Thomas Willett . 1667 Cornells Steenwyck -, 1668-1670 Thomas Delavall 1671 Matthias Nicolls 1672 John Lawrence 1673 William Dervall 1675 Nicholas De Meyer : 1676 S. Van Courtland 1677 Thomas Delavall 1678

Francis Rombouts 1679 William Dyre 1680-1681 Cornelis Steenwyck 1682-1683 Gabriel Minville  1684 Nicholas Bayard 1685 S. Van Courtland 1686-1687 Peter Delancy 1689-1690 John Lawrence 1691 Abraham de Peyster  1692-1695 William Merritt 1695-1698 Johannes de Peyster 1698-1699: David Provost 1699-1700

1700s

Isaac de Riemer 1700-1701 Thomas Noell 1701-1702 Philip French 1702-1703 William Peartree 1703-1707 Ebenezer Wilson 1707-1710 Jacobus Van Courtland 1710-1711 Caleb Heathcote 1711-1714 John Johnson 1714-1719 Jacobus Van Courtland 1719-1720 Robert Walters 1720-1725

Johannes Jensen 1725-1726 Robert Lurting 1726-1735 Paul Richard I735~I739 John Cruger, Sr 1739-1744 Stephen Bayard 1744-1747 Edward Holland I747~i757 John Cruger, Jr 1757-1766 Whitehead Hicks 1766-1776 David Matthews, Tory 1776-1784 James Duane 1784-1789 Richard Varick 1789-1801

1800s

Edward Livingston 1801-1803 De Witt Clinton 1803-1807 Marinus Willett 1807-1808 De Witt Clinton 1808-1810 Jacob Radcliff 1810-1811 De Witt Clinton 1811-1815 John Ferguson 1815 Jacob Radcliff , 1815-1818 Cadwallader D. Golden 1818-1821 Stephen Allen 1821-1824 William Paulding 1825-1826 Philip Hone 1826-1827 William Paulding 1827-1829 Walter Bowne 1829-1833 Gideon Lee 1833-1834 Cornelius W. Lawrence 1834-1837 Aaron Clark 1837-1839 Isaac L. Varian 1839-1841 Robert H. Morris 1841-1844 James Harper 1844-1845 William F. Havemeyer 1845-1846 Andrew H. Mickle 1846-1847 William V. Brady 1847-1848

William F. Havemeyer 1848-1849 Caleb S. Woodhull 1849-1851 Ambrose C. Kingsland 1851-1853 Jacob A. Westervelt 1853-1855 Fernando Wood 1855-1858 Daniel F. Tiemann 1858-1860 Fernando Wood 1860-1862 George Opdyke 1862-1864 C. Godfrey Günther 1864-1866 John T. Hoffman 1866-1868 T. Coman (acting) 1868 A. Oakey Hall 1869-1872 William F. Havemeyer 1873-1874 S. B. H. Vance (acting) 1874 William H. Wickham 1875-1876 Smith Ely 1877-1878 Edward Cooper 1879-1880 William R. Grace 1881-1882 Franklin Edson 1883-1884 William R. Grace 1885-1886 Abram S. Hewitt 1887-1888 Hugh J. Grant 1889-1892 Thomas F. Gilroy 1893-1894 William L. Strong 1895-1897 Robert A. Van Wyck 1898-1901

Seth Low 1902