The Proposed State of Franklin: America’s Forgotten Fourteenth State

In the tumultuous years following the American Revolution, the fledgling United States faced numerous challenges as it sought to establish a stable and unified nation. Amidst the political and economic chaos of the post-war period, a fascinating and little-known chapter in American history unfolded: the brief existence and eventual demise of the proposed state of Franklin. This proposed state, nestled in what is now eastern Tennessee, provides a compelling story of ambition, local governance, and the complexities of early American politics.


The Birth of Franklin: A Region in Flux

The origins of the state of Franklin can be traced back to the Treaty of Paris in 1783, which ended the American Revolutionary War and recognized the independence of the United States. The new nation was eager to expand westward, and settlers began moving into the Appalachian Mountains and beyond. This migration included the area that would become the proposed state of Franklin.

This region was part of western North Carolina, but the settlers felt neglected by the distant state government. North Carolina struggled to provide adequate protection and services to these remote frontier communities. In response to the settlers’ grievances and financial difficulties, North Carolina ceded its western lands to the federal government in 1784, hoping the Continental Congress would create a new territory.

However, before the transfer was finalized, North Carolina rescinded its cession, leaving the settlers in a state of uncertainty and frustration. These frontier communities, feeling abandoned, decided to take matters into their own hands and form a new state.

The Formation of Franklin

In August 1784, a convention of delegates from the frontier counties met in Jonesborough, Tennessee, and declared the establishment of the state of Franklin. They named their new state in honor of Benjamin Franklin, hoping to gain his support and enhance their legitimacy. Although Franklin himself was skeptical of the endeavor, the name reflected the settlers’ aspirations for recognition and respect.

John Sevier, a war hero and prominent local leader, was elected governor of the state of Franklin. Under Sevier’s leadership, the new state government began to function, establishing courts, collecting taxes, and providing defense against Native American attacks. They even developed a rudimentary constitution, reflecting their desire for self-governance and stability.

John Sevier
John Sevier. Source: Portrait Gallery of the National Society of the Colonial Dames of America In Tennessee

Challenges and Opposition

Despite their efforts, the state of Franklin faced significant challenges. The most immediate problem was gaining recognition and support from both the federal government and neighboring states. The Continental Congress was reluctant to endorse the new state, fearing it would set a dangerous precedent for other regions to break away and form independent states.

North Carolina, meanwhile, strongly opposed the creation of Franklin, viewing it as an illegal secession of its territory. Tensions between Franklin and North Carolina escalated, leading to sporadic skirmishes and a general state of unrest in the region.

Internal Struggles

Map drawn by Wikipedia user Iamvered

The fledgling state of Franklin also faced internal struggles. Economic hardship, political divisions, and conflicts with Native American tribes plagued the new government. The settlers were divided between those who supported the Franklin movement and those who remained loyal to North Carolina.

Moreover, the state of Franklin lacked the financial resources and administrative infrastructure needed to govern effectively. Efforts to establish a stable currency and collect taxes were met with resistance, and the state struggled to provide essential services to its citizens.

The Decline and Fall of Franklin

As the state of Franklin grappled with these challenges, its prospects for survival dimmed. By 1788, the situation had deteriorated to the point where John Sevier and other leaders began to seek reconciliation with North Carolina. Many settlers, disillusioned with the Franklin experiment, welcomed the return to North Carolina’s governance.

North Carolina

In February 1789, North Carolina formally reasserted control over the region, effectively ending the state of Franklin. John Sevier was arrested by North Carolina authorities but was later pardoned and went on to serve as a prominent political figure in the state.

The Legacy of Franklin

Although the state of Franklin was short-lived, its story remains an intriguing and significant chapter in American history. The Franklin episode highlights the challenges of frontier life, the complexities of early American politics, and the enduring desire for self-governance and local control.

The settlers’ struggle for recognition and stability in the face of external opposition and internal divisions is a testament to the resilience and determination of the early American frontier communities. The experience of Franklin also underscored the importance of effective governance and the need for a strong and supportive central authority in the new United States.

Franklin’s Influence on Tennessee

The legacy of the state of Franklin can be seen in the later development of Tennessee. In 1796, Tennessee was admitted to the Union as the 16th state, with many of Franklin’s former leaders, including John Sevier, playing key roles in its establishment. The experience of Franklin helped shape the political landscape of Tennessee and contributed to the region’s sense of identity and independence.

As an affiliate and an Amazon Associate, The History Box earns commission from qualifying Amazon purchases and for other purchases made through links in this post.